A rare look at five young men and women, four of them Amish and one Mennonite, getting their first look at a way of life they have been shielded from since birth. Living in New York City, they trade their horses and buggies for taxis and subways. Ultimately, they will have to face the life altering decision to return to their communities or become “English” – a decision that means being shunned by their family and friends.